Is This Viral Ice Cube Tray Really Worth the Hype? We Put It to the Test

Here's our honest review of the Amazon favorite.

December 06, 2024
By: Amanda Mushro

Related To:

Photo by: Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

One of my favorite afternoon treats is a crisp soda in a glass full of ice. It's the perfect pick-me-up that keeps me going through the end of day duties as a mom.

I'm all about finding small ways to make these everyday moments feel special, so when I kept spotting the fancy Icebreaker Pop ice tray on TikTok and seeing it pop up in my Amazon recommendations, I knew I had to give it a shot.

It's just an ice tray, sure — but if it could make my daily soda experience even a smidge better, I was game to try it. Here's the scoop on how it works, how it held up in my testing and whether or not it's worth adding to your cart.

How Does It Work?

Instead of the usual plastic tray or flimsy silicone mold, the Icebreaker Pop is a neat little gadget that lets you pop out ice cubes with just a squeeze.

The process is simple: fill it with water, top it with the cap and lay it flat in your freezer. When it's frozen, you just give it a squeeze to "pop" out the ice cubes, all without the wrestling match that regular ice trays require.

Photo by: Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

The design is clever. It seals up tightly to keep the water inside, making it spill-proof, which is a win for anyone who's ever created a puddle on their kitchen floor trying to move the ice tray into the freezer.

Because it's compact, it doesn't take up much freezer space. But does it deliver pristine, satisfying cubes that live up to the hype?

Putting It to the Test

My freezer is already jam packed with food, so I was a bit nervous about adding something else to the mix, but I was very happy to see the tray is quite compact and laid flat on top of my kids frozen waffles.

Photo by: Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

After a few hours of patiently waiting — or more accurately, obsessively checking the freezer — I took it out, pushed it on the sides and popped the ice out. It's not rocket science, but I wanted to make sure I was doing it right and it worked. No banging, no cracking, no icy fingers.

I dropped a few cubes into my glass and then topped it with my favorite soda. If you're an ice person, you'll understand — these tiny cubes made my drink all the more refreshing.

Pros

  • Ease of Use: Just fill it up, pop it in the freezer and with a simple squeeze, the ice cubes pop out neatly into your glass or ice bucket.
  • Spill-Proof Design: No leaks here! Once you close the tray, you don't have to worry about sloshing water while you get it into the freezer.
  • Compact and Portable: It's small enough to tuck into any corner of the freezer and since it's spill-proof, you can even bring it along for outdoor events.

Photo by: Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Cons

  • Freezing Time: Patience is key. If you're in a rush, be warned that this tray doesn't make ice any faster than a regular tray.
  • Cube Size: While the cubes are nice, they're on the smaller side, so if you like big, chunky ice for cocktails, you may need to double up.

Bottom Line

Sure, you could use the ice maker in your fridge or a regular old fashioned ice cube tray, the Icebreaker Pop is surprisingly fun to use and gives your drinks an ice-cold upgrade without taking up too much freezer space.

If you're someone who appreciates an elevated drink experience or just loves a gadget that does one job really well, this tray is worth checking out!

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:

Next Up

I Tried This TikTok Viral Can Opener — Is It Worth the Hype?

Get ready to meet your newest kitchen gadget obsession.

Does the Wad-Free Bed Sheet Detangler Really Work? We Put It to the Test

This tiny addition to your laundry routine may make a huge difference.

I'm The Chef Too! Has the Cutest Baking Kits for Kids

I’ve tried a lot of baking kits and these are my favorite.

The Best (and Safest) Way to Clean Your Hardwood Floors

Skip the overflowing buckets of water. This is how experts say you should be cleaning your hardwood floors.

This Sparkling Beverage Is Female-Founded, Female-Led, & Absolutely Delicious

Crack open a can that tastes amazing and supports your gut health!

You Need This Giant, Budget-Friendly Pet Lint Roller

This lint roller will become your best friend.

These Cozy Pajamas Feature Your Kid's Favorite Book Characters

We just wish they made these adorable PJs in adult sizes!