These Affordable Baking Sheets Are a Must-Have in Every Kitchen

Three flat sides are a game changer.

July 23, 2024
Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies on Baking Sheet

855113930

Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies on Baking Sheet

Photo by: sorendls

sorendls

By: Amanda Mushro

Related To:

Baking can be a joy or a disaster, depending on the tools you use.  Even with a great recipe, there are so many places where the delicious treats can go wrong. So, after noticing that my baking sheets were looking a little too well loved, I decided to try a new set.

However, the new set had three flat sides so after baking cookies just slid right off to the cooling rack. Since baking sheets are basic, I was excited to try something different. 

After testing the GoodCook AirPerfect Insulated Nonstick Baking Cookie Sheets, I can confidently say these baking sheets fall squarely in the "joy" category. Let's dive into the details of why these sheets are a game-changer for your kitchen.

First Impressions

When I first unwrapped the GoodCook AirPerfect Baking Sheets, I was struck by their sleek appearance. The nonstick coating glistened under the kitchen lights, promising easy clean-up and perfect bakes. The most intriguing feature, though, was the design: three flat sides and one slightly raised edge. This unique structure immediately piqued my interest, hinting at effortless cookie removal and versatile use.

Photo by: Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Results

Using these sheets for the first time was an absolute delight. I decided to bake a batch of classic chocolate chip cookies. As promised, the cookies slid right off the sheets without a hitch, thanks to those three flat sides. No more wrestling with spatulas or worrying about broken cookies!

The cookies themselves baked evenly, with a beautiful golden-brown finish. The insulated design of the sheets helps distribute heat more consistently, preventing those dreaded burnt edges or undercooked centers.

Photo by: Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

Courtesy of Amanda Mushro

I also tried my hand at baking a pizza, and while the flat sides are great for sliding off cookies, I quickly learned (the hard way) that they require a bit more caution with more substantial items. Move too fast, and your pizza might end up on the floor instead of the oven.

Where Can You Get These Cookie Sheets?

Grab yourself a set at Target!

Pros

  • Effortless Release: The standout feature is the design. The three flat sides makes it incredibly easy to slide cookies, pastries and other baked goods right off the sheet. No more sticky situations!
  • Even Baking: Thanks to the insulated construction, these sheets ensure that your cookies and other treats bake evenly. Say goodbye to burnt bottoms and unevenly cooked goodies.
  • Nonstick Surface: Cleaning up after baking is a breeze. The nonstick coating lives up to its name, making residue and stuck-on food a thing of the past.
  • Versatility: These sheets aren't just for cookies. They handle everything from roasting vegetables to baking pizzas — just be careful with that last one.

Cons

  • Flat Sides Require Caution: As much as we love the flat sides for easy cookie removal, they can be a bit of a challenge when handling larger or heavier items like pizzas. If you're not careful, you may end up with your food on the floor.
  • Size: While the medium and large sizes are great for most baking needs, some might find them a bit cumbersome to store, especially if you have limited kitchen space.

Bottom Line

The GoodCook AirPerfect Insulated Nonstick Baking Cookie Sheets are a fantastic addition to any kitchen. Their innovative design, combined with excellent performance, makes them a standout choice for bakers of all levels. Whether you're an occasional cookie-maker or a baking enthusiast, these sheets will quickly become a go-to in your kitchen arsenal.

The easy-release feature of the three flat sides is a game-changer, ensuring your baked goods slide off effortlessly. Just remember to handle larger items with care to avoid any spills.

The even baking and nonstick surface only add to the appeal, making cleanup quick and painless. If you're looking to upgrade your baking sheets, this set is well worth the investment.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:

Next Up

This Adorable Fridge Deodorizer Will Keep Your Kitchen Fresh

A fungi-tastic way to keep your fridge fresh!

This Garment Duffel Bag Is a Travel Must-Have

It's a garment bag. It's a duffel. It's going to be your new favorite piece of luggage!

I’m Obsessed With My Allbirds Sneakers — Here’s Why You’ll Want a Pair

A fun, vintage feel and super comfortable — meet my new favorite sneakers.

Our Favorite Fall Coats

These trendy options will keep you stylish all season.

Battle of the Most Popular Dry Shampoos

I tested out three of the most popular dry shampoos – here's what I liked and didn't like about each one.

This Cuddly Toy Brings Comfort to Kids — Here's Why My Son Adores His

Here's a plush animal you won't mind adding to your kid's collection.

Summer Skorts Are So In — Here Are Our Favorites

Running errands or running to the pickleball court, we love skorts in the summer.

Summer Mother of the Bride Looks You'll Love

Because it's a special day for mom too!

Wedding Day Essentials for the Bride & Bridal Party

These six items take some stress away from the big day!