These Fun Peanut Butter Flavors and Other Nut and Nut-Free Spreads Will Upgrade Your Traditional PB&J

Sandwich making will never be the same.

Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money off these affiliate links. Learn more.

September 28, 2022

By: Jessica Butler

Related To:

Shop This Look

View The Gallery

1 / 9

Not Your Average Nut Butters

From delicious spins on regular peanut butter to fun-flavored nut and nut-free butters, these spreads will pair perfectly with jellies, jams, fruits, and seeds — or you can dig right in with your favorite spoon. Take your kids’ lunches to the next level and treat yourself to a satisfying, protein-packed snack any time of the day. Which butter would you love to try out first?

Legendary Foods Chocolate Banana Flavored Peanut Butter

Peanut butter, chocolate, and bananas — we couldn’t name a better combo. As delicious (and indulgent) as this spread sounds, it only contains 1 gram of sugar and no trans fats. So, slice up a banana for even more flavor and enjoy this dessert-like spread.

BUY IT: Amazon, $12.99

Oat Haus Organic Vanilla Granola Butter

Many schools have nut-free cafeterias to avoid potential allergies, so this oat-based butter would be perfect for your kiddo’s lunch. The main ingredients are gluten-free oats, maple syrup, olive oil, and coconut oil, so you won’t have to worry. The vanilla flavor adds a little something special as well.

BUY IT: Amazon, $12.95

88 Acres Dark Chocolate Sunflower Seed Butter

Sunflower seed butters are especially popular in nut-free schools, and with delectable flavors like these, we're not suprised! Try 88 Acres' dark chocolate, vanilla cinnamon, and original maple sunflower seed butters individually or order the whole trio for some variety.

BUY IT: 88 Acres, $29.99

ButterflyCinnamon Vanilla Elevated Nut Butter

Walnuts, cashews, macadamia nuts, and MCT oil combined to give you this nutrient-rich nut butter. The texture is a bit granulated, but never gritty — much like "sugar cookie dough," one Amazon reviewer noted. It’s also been dubbed a great "keto butter" and it’s full of antioxidants.

BUY IT: Amazon, $14.95

Big Spoon Roasters Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter

Carrot cake in a jar?! This almond and walnut butter aims to mimic the flavor of scrumptious carrot cake that you can spread over whatever you want. It contains heart-healthy fats and it would pair nicely with sweet fruits or jams.

BUY IT: Amazon, $17.99

Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter - Oatmeal Cookie

Not only is this butter’s label absolutely adorable, but it also contains Omega 3 fatty acids (thanks, walnuts!) and will definitely satisfy a cookie craving. This brand makes yummy walnut snacks in all sorts of flavors that match their butters as well.

BUY IT: Amazon, $10.99

Nuts ‘N More Chocolate Maple Pretzel Peanut Butter Spread

We’ve never seen this peanut butter flavor before and that’s what makes Nuts ‘N More such a one-of-a-kind brand. They specialize in low carb, low sugar, gluten free, non-GMO, and high protein nut butters and powders in fun flavors your whole family will enjoy.

BUY IT: Amazon, $14.27

Nuts ‘N More Birthday Cake Peanut Butter Spread

Treat every day like a birthday with this birthday cake-flavored peanut butter. According to many Amazon reviews, this just might be the jar you reserve for your spoon snacking.

BUY IT: Amazon, $14.27

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Cold Lunch Ideas for School, New Guidelines on Preventing Food Allergies in Babies – Here's What Parents Need to Know, Exciting News for Peanut Allergy Parents — Researchers Say There Are Two Treatments That Induce Peanut Allergy Remission in Kids

Follow TLC on Apple News